Death of Strength Training
Posted on Mar 14th, 2006
by
Rob
How is it possible that strength training is steadily growing in numbers yet at the same time slowly dying and withering away?
Well, It's certainly possible because this is exactly what is happening. At least that's my biased opinion.
On the surface gyms are popping up everywhere and companies are flocking to developing wellness programs like it's the internet before the bubble popped - or if you prefer - like a 16 year old hopping on mom and dad's high speed connection to find a porn site.
Gym memberships are up, the number of gyms is increasing almost daily and the number of people who incorporate some form of strength training in their exercise continues to grow.
So what's the problem?
Well if you just look at the exterior of the situation - those stats and figures - there isn't one.
But if you go into a gym, just about any one of them, and you take a look at the interior - both your own, those around you as well as the shared space within a gym I think you'll agree, something's wrong.
(yea we're talking about the left side of the quadrants you integral freaks!)
Here's some of what I've noticed.
Most people aren't enjoying themselves.
Next time you're there, take a look around and see if you can catch some joy, happiness or excitement while someone's lifting weights or engaged in some other form of strength training. Honestly, it's a difficult task to find someone who's whole heartedly enjoying themselves.
Most people seem to just be going through the motions.
When I talk to people here and there at my gym, I don't find a whole lot of passion and drive. In fact, the conversation almost always goes to something else. It is as if people are implicitly saying, "there's nothing to talk about with regards to lifting weights, why would anyone talk about that?"
Not that there is anything intrinsically wrong with this, but it does display the mind's tendency to go elsewhere, away from strength training.
Sometimes I'll just look around and watch for a few minutes and connect with all that's going on around me. That's when I get the biggest sense that most people are just going through the motions - physically they are on what seems to be an autopilot.
When I look at someone I can usually feel what's going on within them. The body communicates so fully that sometimes I don't even feel like I need to have a conversation with them to know their interior.
(Hey, either I'm really dialed in or I'm really starting to master this whole "projection" process really well!)
Sometimes, it's just a complete checkout. Like the guy who was working his shoulders while watching TV last night. It was as if the human being - the part of him that animates his aliveness from within - simply wasn't there. Body on auto pilot doing one thing, mind on auto pilot watching some crappy game of baseball.
Another woman broke my heart a few months ago as she was struggling with something while she was working out, her struggle appeared to be very intense. It was radiating from her like a distress beacon cutting through the night. I felt as though she was just on the edge of holding things together.
What was tearing her up inside was the fact that she didn't have any more chocolate Full Strength nutrition shakes. This existential uncertainty was...ok, obviously just kidding...
One of my least favorite things to watch is a trainer and trainee working "hard" together as they talk throughout an entire set... about skiing. And this guy is getting paid for that! He's considered a professional of sorts? Good lord, no wonder this strength training thing is heading south (just a play on words here - I've got nothing against the south!!!)
Most people aren't really fully engaging themselves.
What I'm getting at is most people don't fully engage themselves in strength training.
Now I get that there are different levels of engagement, but the vast majority of what I see is the opposite.
Dis-connected, Dis-engaged, Dis-empowered.
People must feel deeply obligated to train in order to maintain this pursuit. It's the "I should" strength train story line. I think this approach to strength training is killing this beautifully rich discipline.
So many people are not becoming more alive, engaged and aware through their strength training. Too many people numb out, go through the motions, dissociate from their current activity and then feel relieved once they're done.
Why?
My guess is because the obligation has been lifted for a brief amount of time.
Strength training has a short and strange history - beyond the scope of this blog - but it's birth was born out of people who had at least an interest in developing their strength. The individuals who have carried this discipline forward are those who fell in love with the practice.
Why did they fall in love with moving iron around?
I ultimately don't know.
Personally though I've found a discipline that challenges me to wake up, passionately engage in my life and find a meaning and depth in my life that quite honestly does not as vividly arise in any other sphere of activity.
I write this in hopes that people who strength train can bring their struggles, their conventional day to day habits, their desires as well as their vivid passion for life and bring it all into their training.
I hope that the woman who broke my heart wide open can bring her suffering into her training in a way that fuels her greater unfolding.
I hope this inspires someone to tell their trainer to shut the fuck up, to let them be in this brilliantly painful moment without adding yet another distraction from what really matters.
I hope that strength training can be a place where we can bring our habitual tendency's, but instead of just playing them out like an old record stuck at the end of the track, I hope we can learn to confront these habits set by set, moment to moment while we dance with weights.
I hope people can begin to step beyond their conventional level of engagement and feel the ebbing bliss hiding within the intensity of a really great set.
I hope more people can know the radiant ecstasy that flows up the spine, the formless stillness that settles into an infinite space, and the tears that embrace both suffering and joy.
Yes all that and the oddly strange surroundings of all too often bad music, strange guys either checking you out or sizing you up along side the sea of unconsciousness of those who physically came but have yet to really show up, running on autopilot hoping to get in shape some day.
Perhaps in the strangest of circumstances, we can breath life, real life, into a discipline that's both growing and dying.
Regardless, I'm looking forward to having some more authentic company as I'll be dancing with the weights later on tonight.
Peace,
Rob

Help




Great post, Rob. Although I’ve been a slack-ass with the weights in the last month or two, I am also a bit troubled by the lack of real passion for strength training. Not that everyone needs to dig strength training, but there’s gotta be more folks out there than who I come across! Most folks are following “a should” mentality and that’s really hard to maintain over the long run. I know that I would enjoy my training even more if I had someone else who was equally excited about ST. Question is, if that’s the common mind state with ST, how to positively influence others to encourage a change?
ryan
“I hope this inspires someone to tell their trainer to shut the fuck up, to let them be in this brilliantly painful moment without adding yet another distraction from what really matters.”
AMEN!!!
I need to get back into strength training; but… I am the sort that needs the training companion… not to have someone to talk to or anything like that… I am a quiet trainer… I just need a trainer to tell me what to do and make sure the movements are correct. I was so spoiled before when I trained with a b/f… everything was written/planned out for me.
I find your post quite inspiring to get back into it!!! Thanks for the motivation! Now to find someone to write up a workout plan! HAHA!!
Here Here…
Great post. I am a woman who adores strength training. Truth is, I'll go kicking and screaming to do my cardio, but strength training has a magnetic draw for me. Makes me feel tapped into my core power, my passion, my raw energy. It feels sexy and fierce, not to mention the immense sense of accomplishment and satisfaction I get in the moment, and then later when I feel the strength and power I can conjur from my body.
Having just re-read that, you'd think I was a body builder… but no. Just a fan of testing my endurance.
~jodi
Hi Rob:
Thanks for this great post. You’ve pretty much hit the nail on the head. These are the reasons that I’ve never been able to keep myself going regularly to a gym (other than the fact that I’m amazingly lazy!) I’ve never wanted to be in that environment.
At least with FIT, I have a model of the “environment” I can carry around with me in my head while I’m there.
Rigzin
Rob. Well done. Really appreciate this blog. Your thoughtfulness, smarts, and great commentary are the ingrediants of a best-seller book! Rock it out, big boy.
oh my gosh - this is so true - people don’t look like they are having fun - no laughing no running around - I dance a little as I run on the treadmill and I feel so self conscous - but I wanna have fun!
but i love checking out women in the gym :) seriously, i do my best to stay focus. even keep my workouts within an hour. my iPod Nano is very handy. i can focus more if i'm listening to Spin Doctors and Blues Traveler than chatting with hot females. but i still check them out. and once i'm done, i head out to the nearest sushi place and do mindful eating. but dang, there are still lots of hot asian women there. that's the time when a cold shower really helps.
Another great muse, Rob. Ah, so true.
Hey, but if I were at your gym, you would find joy in response to your questions. If each of us who takes joy and has passion about strength training (at least the true training) and shares this when asked at the gym, Truth can be contageous. When I am asked, often it is with utter shock the person asking appears as I launch into my philosophy (only part of it with physical strength, but one cannot talk about one without the other three forms, no?) - with passion they indeed are not accustomed. Every so often, this all goes right over their green heads, and at the end I get a “wow, so you do not compete? You don't do this for competition?” Yet, every so often, I catch the faintest of acknowledgement in understanding what I am saying.
Thanks for everything.
Peace through Strength,
Christopher
Another great muse, Rob. Ah, so true.
Hey, but if I were at your gym, you would find joy in response to your questions. If each of us who takes joy and has passion about strength training (at least the true training) and shares this when asked at the gym, Truth can be contageous. When I am asked, often it is with utter shock the person asking appears as I launch into my philosophy (only part of it with physical strength, but one cannot talk about one without the other three forms, no?) - with passion they indeed are not accustomed. Every so often, this all goes right over their green heads, and at the end I get a “wow, so you do not compete? You don't do this for competition?” Yet, every so often, I catch the faintest of acknowledgement in understanding what I am saying.
Thanks for everything.
Peace through Strength,
Christopher